Forecasting Ebola: Use Past Data or Spot the Difference? Cercle K2 - Cercle K2 [ ![](/img/logo-k2.png) ](/) [关于](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN#about) [成员](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/membres-fondateurs) 团队 [ 管理层 战略方向 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/college-de-la-gerance) [ 执行委员会 决策执行 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-executif) [ 道德准则委员会 保证遵循尊重创始价值观 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-ethique) [ 战略委员会 勤思创新 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-strategique) [文章](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes) ### 最新发布 - [ ![La poudre en onze mois. Et les soudeurs ?](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6741/conversions/JFD-5-2-medium.jpg) #### La poudre en onze mois. Et les soudeurs ? 22/10/2026 Jean-François Delaforge ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/la-poudre-en-onze-mois-et-les-soudeurs) - [ ![L’OSINT augmenté par l’IA : instrument pour le renseignement ?](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6729/conversions/karima-bouaiss-octo-2026-medium.jpg) #### L’OSINT augmenté par l’IA : instrument pour le renseignement ? 20/10/2026 Karima Bouaiss ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/l-osint-augmente-par-l-ia-instrument-pour-le-renseignement) - [ ![Nous sommes tous des modèles de langage ?](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6725/conversions/Mathieu-Guide%CC%80re-OCT26-K2-medium.jpg) #### Nous sommes tous des modèles de langage ? 15/10/2026 Mathieu Guidère ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/nous-sommes-tous-des-modeles-de-langage) - [ ![Vers un continuum entre sécurité et justice Pour une communauté de protection au service de l’État de droit](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6713/conversions/Mohamed-Douhane-K2-sep-26-medium.jpg) #### Vers un continuum entre sécurité et justice Pour une communauté de protection au serv... 12/10/2026 Mohamed Douhane ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/vers-un-continuum-entre-securite-et-justice-pour-une-communaute-de-protection-au-service-de-l-etat-de-droit) - [ ![Du bipartisme](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6675/conversions/francis-beau-ete-26-k2-medium.jpg) #### Du bipartisme 08/10/2026 Francis Beau ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/du-bipartisme) - [ !["On lève l'ancre." : Ce que la résilience doit aux équipes, pas aux plans.](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6673/conversions/philippe-horras-ete-26-k2-medium.jpg) #### "On lève l'ancre." : Ce que la résilience doit aux équipes, pas aux plans. 01/10/2026 Philippe Horras ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/on-leve-l-ancre-ce-que-la-resilience-doit-aux-equipes-pas-aux-plans) [所有发布 →](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes) 行动 [ Groupes K2 思想工作 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/groupes-k2) [ Trophées K2 促进研究 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/trophees-k2) Choix ![zh_CN](/img/zh.png) [ ![](/img/fr.png) Français ](https://cercle-k2.fr/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/en.png) English ](https://cercle-k2.fr/en/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/zh.png) 中文 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/es.png) Español ](https://cercle-k2.fr/es/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/pt.png) Português ](https://cercle-k2.fr/pt/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/de.png) Deutsche ](https://cercle-k2.fr/de/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ LinkedIn ![](/img/linkedin.svg) ](https://www.linkedin.com/company/cercle-k2/posts/?feedView=all&viewAsMember=true) Cercle K2 [Présentation](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN#about) [创始成员](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/membres-fondateurs) [所有发布](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes) 团队 [ Collège de la gérance 管理层 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/college-de-la-gerance) [ Comité Exécutif 执行委员会 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-executif) [ Comité d'Ethique 道德准则委员会 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-ethique) [ Comité Stratégique 战略委员会 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-strategique) 行动 [Groupes K2](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/groupes-k2) [Trophées K2](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/trophees-k2) [联系我们](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/contactez-nous) [ LinkedIn ![](/img/linkedin.svg) Linkedin ](https://www.linkedin.com/company/cercle-k2/mycompany/?viewAsMember=true) [ ![](/img/fr.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/en.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/en/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/zh.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/es.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/es/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/pt.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/pt/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/de.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/de/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) Forecasting Ebola: Use Past Data or Spot the Difference? ========================================================== [ ![Gilles Hilary - Cercle K2](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/1170/conversions/214-preview.jpg) ](#) [Gilles Hilary](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/users/single/214/Gilles-Hilary) 23/01/2015 - 2 min. de lecture - [](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) - [](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Default+share+text&url=https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) - [](https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite?mini=true&url=https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63&title=Default+share+text&summary=) ![Forecasting Ebola: Use Past Data or Spot the Difference? - Cercle K2](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/177/conversions/63-large.jpg) Cercle K2对所有发布观点既不赞同也不反对，所有观点态度仅属于作者个人。 **Different approaches used by Médecins Sans Frontières and the World Health Organisation to identify the threat of Ebola led to opposite conclusions. This highlights the role of organisational culture when addressing new and ambiguous developments.** On March 31st this year, [Médecins Sans Frontières](https://www.google.com.sg/search?es_sm=122&q=M%C3%A9decins+Sans+Fronti%C3%A8res&sa=X&ei=UttRVIPmFOHNmwWnmYDICA&ved=0CBoQ7xYoAA) (MSF or Doctors without Borders) declared that the world was “facing an epidemic of a magnitude never before seen in terms of the distribution of cases” referring to the spread of Ebola cases across Guinea. The very next day, on April 1st, the World Health Organisation (WHO) insisted that “this is relatively small still; the biggest outbreaks have been over 400 cases.” Their key decision on whether to declare the outbreak a global health emergency was not made by the WHO until August 8th. #### #### **Seeing it differently** WHO and MSF both have a strong expertise and share in many ways the same epidemiologic knowledge. How was it, then, that these two organisations did not see the same thing when the first Ebola cases were reported? Both organisations had two entirely different ways of looking at the early signs of the epidemic. The WHO used its existing understanding of the disease to make a forecast that extrapolated past crises. From the WHO’s perspective, on March 31st the situation didn’t look threatening. The number of suspected cases stood at 122, which was around the average number of cases over the 20 previous outbreaks that occurred since 1976. The 122 cases were also three times lower than the highest number of cases in an outbreak previously experienced at that point. Importantly, none of the previous outbreaks had required a costly international health response, as they remained far away from the “tipping point” which determines when epidemics get out of control. In contrast, MSF first collected a series of unusual points, such as the emergence of cases in several places at the same time, the fact that the outbreak was at the border of three countries and that it was the first time the outbreak had appeared in West Africa, which had an inadequate healthcare system. #### **Understanding the unusual** MSF then saw something different unfolding in Guinea. Rather than using past data to determine whether the outbreak was reaching its tipping point or not, it tried to connect the dots of the sparsely spreading illness. MSF Director General, Bruno Jochum said it was remarkable that the outbreak had spread to several places including Conakry, a city of around 2 million people. “These two characteristics make it an exceptional event for an Ebola outbreak up until today,” he said. Both organisations, therefore, were dealing with the same information and understanding of how Ebola spread. Both were aware of the dramatic costs if the outbreak reached its tipping point. The difference, however, was that the WHO approached the problem as a known process, while MSF framed it as an issue to disambiguate. #### **Differing approaches** There could be at least two reasons for the different approaches. First, in 2009, the WHO declared its first ever “public health emergency of international concern” when H1N1, or Swine Flu, started to spread and advised countries to monitor citizens for outbreaks. This, however, appeared to be a false positive and the organisation was accused of being too alarmist. Naturally, the counterfactual is missing and we do not know what would have happened if the WHO did not intervene. However, this may have led the WHO to be too careful when declaring global health emergencies. A second reason is that the WHO has also been increasingly earmarking budgets to focus on dealing with projects and execution. While such projects are of huge importance in the health of millions, it has meant less “flexible funding” to cope with pandemics. It essentially frames the world in a very structured way. This is not necessarily a bad thing. When you have a structure, you have a more immediate and predictable impact. However, when procedures are too structured, organisations will face challenges dealing with the ambiguous or the unknown. Organisations that are too focused are more likely to frame ambiguous situations in previously observed patterns as the WHO did, relying too much on functioning within boundaries as opposed to actively collecting and connecting unusual dots. This is a particularly important issue when one is facing a potentially “explosive” situation like pandemics, where missing the tipping point has catastrophic consequences. Even when knowledge and expertise is identical, differences in culture can lead to radically different responses to new and ambiguous developments. 23/01/2015 - [](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) - [](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Default+share+text&url=https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) - [](https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite?mini=true&url=https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63&title=Default+share+text&summary=) #### 最新发布 [ ![La poudre en onze mois. Et les soudeurs ? - Cercle K2](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6741/conversions/JFD-5-2-medium.jpg) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/la-poudre-en-onze-mois-et-les-soudeurs) [### La poudre en onze mois. Et les soudeurs ? Jean-François Delaforge est Responsable Relations Sociales Europe et transnationales de BNP Paribas. --- La poudre en onze mois. Et les soude... ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/la-poudre-en-onze-mois-et-les-soudeurs) [ ![Jean-François Delaforge](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6482/conversions/Jean-Franc%CC%A7ois-Delaforge-k2-vf-preview.jpg) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/users/single/1841/Jean-Fran%C3%A7ois-Delaforge) [Jean-François Delaforge](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/users/single/1841/Jean-Fran%C3%A7ois-Delaforge) 22/10/2026 [ ![L’OSINT augmenté par l’IA : instrument pour le renseignement ? - Cercle K2](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6729/conversions/karima-bouaiss-octo-2026-medium.jpg) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/l-osint-augmente-par-l-ia-instrument-pour-le-renseignement) [### L’OSINT augmenté par l’IA : instrument pour le renseignement ? Karima Bouaiss est Professeur agrégé des Universités – Université de Lille, Conseiller du commerce extér... ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/l-osint-augmente-par-l-ia-instrument-pour-le-renseignement) [ ![Karima Bouaiss](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6635/conversions/karima-bouaiss-k2-preview.jpg) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/users/single/1878/Karima-Bouaiss) [Karima Bouaiss](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/users/single/1878/Karima-Bouaiss) 20/10/2026 [ ![Nous sommes tous des modèles de langage ? - Cercle K2](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6725/conversions/Mathieu-Guide%CC%80re-OCT26-K2-medium.jpg) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/nous-sommes-tous-des-modeles-de-langage) [### Nous sommes tous des modèles de langage ? Mathieu Guidère est Professeur des universités et directeur de recherches à l’INSERM. --- L’humanité a... ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/nous-sommes-tous-des-modeles-de-langage) [ ![Mathieu Guidère](https://cercle-k2.fr/storage/6134/conversions/ProfMathieuGuidere-25-preview.jpg) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/users/single/380/Mathieu-Guid%C3%A8re) [Mathieu Guidère](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/users/single/380/Mathieu-Guid%C3%A8re) 15/10/2026 [ 所有发布 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes) Footer ------ ![Cercle K2](/img/logo-k2.png) 自成立以来，CERCLE K2 俱乐部就为来自各行各业的职业人士之间的会面和对话开辟了空间。俱乐部是一个多学科（50 多个职业的代表和 2000 多名会员）、代际（K2 职业生涯路线规划项目、K2 课程等）和国际性（代表 30 多个国家）交流平台。 [ ![](/img/fr.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/en.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/en/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/zh.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/es.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/es/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/pt.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/pt/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ ![](/img/de.png) ](https://cercle-k2.fr/de/etudes/forecasting-ebola-use-past-data-or-spot-the-difference-63) [ LinkedIn ![](/img/linkedin.svg) ](https://www.linkedin.com/company/cercle-k2/posts/?feedView=all&viewAsMember=true) ### Présentation - [关于](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN#about) - [ 管理层 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/college-de-la-gerance) - [ 执行委员会 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-executif) - [ 道德准则委员会 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-ethique) - [ 战略委员会 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/gouvernance/comite-strategique) - [ 成员 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/membres) ### 行动 - [ Groupes K2 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/groupes-k2) - [ Trophées K2 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/trophees-k2) - [ 联系我们 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/contactez-nous) - [ Espace membre ](https://cercle-k2.fr/login) ### 文章 - [ 所有发布 ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes) - [ La poudre en onze mois. Et les s... ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/la-poudre-en-onze-mois-et-les-soudeurs?id=1892) - [ L’OSINT augmenté par l’IA : inst... ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/l-osint-augmente-par-l-ia-instrument-pour-le-renseignement?id=1890) - [ Nous sommes tous des modèles de... ](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/etudes/nous-sommes-tous-des-modeles-de-langage?id=1888) © 2012-2026 版权所有 - [法律声明](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/mentions-l%C3%A9gales) - [Protection des données personnelles](https://cercle-k2.fr/zh_CN/politique-de-protection-des-donn%C3%A9es-personnelles) - Cookie 设置